WashingTone-Locian Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Tim45 Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
>
> > While I believe in capitalism I also believe it
> is
> > morally wrong to take government tax breaks and
> > contracts while shipping jobs offshore.
>
>
> Morality has never had anything to do with
> capitalism and vice versa. Capitalism is about
> making a profit. The only way to keep government
> contracting jobs from going overseas is for the
> Federal government to require that those jobs are
> kept in the U.S. However, in order to do that,
> that means more cost to American taxpayers.
>
> The truth is, American workers can no longer
> compete with the world when it comes to
> low-paying, low-skill jobs. And, in fact, many
> so-called "middle skill" positions are now more
> easily filled overseas.
>
> The best way for America to create good quality
> jobs is to push for innovation in green
> technologies, stem cell research, advanced
> manufacturing, etc. That's one area I have been
> disappointed in with Obama. Why are we cutting
> jobs for rocket scientists while creating jobs for
> people to shovel gravel? Stupid.
WTL, are you really that naive? It sounds like you are old enough to understand reality better than just going "green jobs, blah blah blah" as if somehow that mantra will create jobs.
Look at Spain, who was doing the "green jobs" thing for years now. They have already shown that for all the green jobs created, they have lost something between 2-3 jobs in other positions. Not much of a winning strategy there.
China and India both are developing much better higher education centers and research facilities, and they both have such large populations that they can fill all the jobs in high tech from here to eternity. And therein lies the problem - it is just cheaper to hire workers in China and India, and have them do the work. Look at green jobs - where did the contracts go to buy wind turbines? China or Germany.
http://www.popsci.com/technology/article/2009-10/huge-texas-wind-turbines-will-be-made-china
Sure, we have a few small businesses in the field, but China is like the Microsoft version of a manufacturing country. They can opt to build everything with generally the same quality but much cheaper than their competitors - and they do this on a regular basis to keep competition down in other nations.
We have a problem with labor (and some supply) costs (look at what they are paying all the folks with active security clearances - it is at least double the going rate for a non-cleared position. This also extends into manufacturing - every time we try to setup any kind of "factory" it is inevitable that a union will attempt to, or be formed. It isn't that the workers have unfair wages, or lack of insurance - the law sees to that. No, it is that they want to be paid the equivalent money to do low skill jobs that someone is paid with advanced degrees. And also get the equivalent benefits. That is the kind of thing that hurts capitalism - especially when you are competing with countries that have other labor standards. That doesn't mean we should pay slave wages for our workers, but certainly there can be a more equitable, competitive pay for assembly line workers that doesn't mean they have to lead impoverished lives. That would allow for the growth of our industries manufacturing industries again - in whatever area - and be competitive. Even selling to ourselves - it is ridiculous that it was cheaper to buy steel made in China and shipped here from overseas, then it was to make it in our own backyard.
Yeah and sorry, but if we have to import all our raw materials for whatever it is we produce, we are beholden to world markets to set our low end pricing. If we are unwilling to use our natural resources to support our industrial base we really have little to complain about when our costs shoot through the roof due to supply shortages - especially when that commodity would be available in the US but "off limits" due to environmental concerns. That same holds true for the price of energy - if we keep following policies that allow for electric prices to go UP - then it doesn't matter if we have green cars or not. You will be paying to heat your homes, or maybe recharge your electric, no emission, car that there will be no way to change the long term trends.
The issue is much more "Gray" than just "create green jobs, stem cell research, blather". And yeah, too bad the Democrats, int heir zeal to push stimulus funding, forgot to push for all that huh?
If you can’t model the past, where you know the answer pretty well, how can you model the future? - William Happer Cyrus Fogg Brackett Professor of Physics Princeton University