spunky Wrote:
>
> So, the Native Americans would have eventually
> destroyed themselves so it's
> just as well we destroyed them ourselves? Does
> that pretty much sum up your post RV? I want to
> make sure I am not guilty of putting words in
> youor mouth?
Quote
Posted by: sk8ter bOI ()
Date: December 16, 2008 02:11AM
Well put, spunky. They lived in true freedom. We just brought tyranny, bankerism, and oppression. I truly morn for the indigenous Americans.
America murdered over 500 independent nations to conquer this continent. Our history began as a genocide.
I then respond with:
Quote
As did almost any other country that exists on the planet today....\
And some other thoughts about them probably being exploited by some other country.
WHY?
Because they were a tribal society with loose affiliations. Even with the threat of the "white man" they were unable and unwilling to come together as a nation and fight them off. There was NO Indian Nation in the US to begin with. There were Indians, yes.
What I was pointing out was, if you look at just about ANY OTHER COUNTRY in the world today, they were created off of the backs of, or due to the killing of, some other race or tribe that existed before them. That was how the world evolved - strange huh? Not really - tribal evolution has been well documented throughout the world. The name of the game was adapt, or be replaced - and that is what happened (unfortunately) to the American Indian.
Do I lament this? To some degree yes, because they had a society that was unique and interesting. Does this mean I should throw everything over and let them take over what may have, at one time, been theirs to claim? No. Again, something I stated in response to Vince (which he still doesn't understand); Measuring Today's results by Today's reality is not meaningful in any way other than as a way to torture yourself. Meaning, back when all this happened, there were a lot of other issues on the table, and the reality that those folks lived in dictated the choices they made (good or bad) - today we look at how it all turned out and go "man, too bad all that happened". Not that they would have known, thought, or cared about any of this back then, because they were faced with a much different set of conditions then what we are looking at today. Would the world be different? Sure. Would it be better? How could you ever know? So, leave it at the fact that we are here now, and this is what we are faced with, and lets try to make it better for EVERYONE, and make the best of it. Sitting here lamenting over the "possibility" that life would be better today if they had been left alone is merely speculative "grass is greener on the other side" BS.
EDIT: If the American Indians had never encountered the "white man" - there is no telling what kind of nation (if any) would be here today. That was my point. Nice history, but meaningless in moving forward other than trying not to repeat it to some other group of people in the future.
Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 12/18/2008 02:24PM by Registered Voter.