Re: Craigslist baby for sale in Annandale...WTF?
Date: January 12, 2011 06:15AM
Spacy Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> SNAFU Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
> > Quite a prank that will, in the end, prove to
> be
> > not worth it, considering it' s in violation of
> > Virginia law and, since it involves even
> > 'supposed' minor children, will most likely
> lead
> > to felony charges.
> >
> >
> > "...the investigation is continuing because
> > Virginia's adoption law prohibits anyone from
> > accepting any money for the placement of a
> child,
> > and 'No person shall advertise or solicit to
> > perform any activity prohibited' by the law."
>
> The facts are (a) there was no baby and no illegal
> activity and (b) the "advertisement" was a very
> obvious joke, a parody on the pet-selling ads.
> Given the enforcement against those facts, the
> Constitutionality of the law itself is called into
> question.
From the craigslist ad:
"sorry if you think this is wrong but we think the best way of insuring a happy life for her is to give her to an affluent couple that wants to have kids enogh [sic] to pay for it. pics on request."
I am sorry, but how does offering a baby over the internet for money ( regardless if it is a 'joke') not constitute an illegal and criminal act? (see below)
"Virginia's adoption law prohibits anyone from accepting any money for the placement of a child, and 'No person shall ADVERTISE or SOLICIT to perform any activity prohibited' by the law." - The Washington Post
Also, how could any rational human being see this as being funny or a 'joke' ? If you use your rationale, then it should be o.k. for someone to threaten violence towards the President over the internet and not be held accountable as long as he or she were just 'joking', right? Are you serious?
>
> This sounds like a strange case of government
> harassment. They already knew that there was no
> baby being sold and that it was obviously a joke.
>
> It's hard to see how the police are going to look
> good coming out of this.
They were within the letter of the law and had probable cause to seize the computer, xbox, and any other conduit to the internet based on the attempted criminal solicitation of the sale of a minor child.