"If you take 2 identical cars, one with a manual, one with an automatic, and race them from a dead stop, the automatic will jump ahead 9 times out of 10. It may not stay in the lead, but it will win off the line."
You're telling me that if I rev to 2.5K rpm and drop the clutch when the light turns green the
same car with an auto is gonna take me off the line? Nope. I have a direct link from flywheel to axle. As soon as the clutch is dropped I'm either gonna rocket forward, or spin the wheels and create a lot of puffy blue smoke.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torque_converter
"Check out the high-powered cars with professional drivers at the dragstrip. Virtually all of them have a transmision that is more like an automatic than a manual."
Those drag cars are using manual transmissions (with clutches and all) with a mechanical device such as air shifters or like devices to shift the cars gears for the driver much faster than he/she could do so themselves. This also allows the driver to keep both hands on the wheel and simply press a button when it's time to shift. If the driver does not press the button in time, the engine tears itself apart. If these cars had true auto trannies in them, the driver would not need to press any buttons, and the car would do everything for them. The VW DSG transmission is the closest thing to the racing transmission you're talking about. Dual wet clutches with even and odd gears spit between the two of them. Gear changes occur in 7 milliseconds.