What do you Think? General Assembly passed a law requiring an ultrasound be performed prior to a woman being allowed to have an abortion procedure.
Debate casts Virginia in negative light
http://www.fairfaxtimes.com/article/20120309/OPINION/703099858/1065/debate-casts-virginia-in-negative-light&template=fairfaxTimes
Last week, the General Assembly passed a law requiring an ultrasound be performed prior to a woman being allowed to have an abortion procedure.
It is not a medically necessary procedure and — against some lawmakers’ wishes —there is no requirement the procedure be covered by insurance.
Depending on your position on this divisive issue, this vote is either a resounding victory or a somewhat bewildering defeat. It’s bewildering because the topic of abortion rights played so small a factor in the fall election.
It was a Republican year. The GOP picked up seats in both houses of the General Assembly, taking tentative control of the Virginia Senate at 20-20 with Lt. Gov. Bill Bolling (R) breaking any ties.
A large part of this success was backlash against Democrats on the national level, and an approval of the Gov. Robert F. McDonnell model: Conservative principles, but with a focus on putting first things first. McDonnell is enjoying high approval ratings for his focus on business and economic development. He has even gone so far as to rein in the far-right of the party when it travels past what the electorate is comfortable with.
For instance, it was McDonnell who announced no government agency would discriminate against gays and lesbians after Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli began to question state universities’ ability to create nondiscrimination statements. It was McDonnell who agreed to update the Local Composite Index to ensure Northern Virginia jurisdictions — largely Democratic-controlled at the time — receive their fair share of school funding. And it was McDonnell who interceded by telling members of the General Assembly that requiring an invasive transvaginal ultrasound before receiving an abortion was taking the matter too far.
Instead, McDonnell has harnessed his energies toward attracting business and increasing the commonwealth’s competitiveness. This business-friendly, fiscal conservative model is what most voters thought they were getting when punching the ballot for the candidate followed with a (R).
In the run-up to last November’s election, most Republican candidates for the General Assembly were glad to share their views on abortion, gun control, immigration or the traditional family, while maintaining the election would hinge on transportation and the economy.
No one indicated the HPV vaccination, “personhood” legislation, revoking the one-gun-per-month rule, drug testing for welfare recipients and easing the “triggerman” rule for the death penalty would use up their political capital for an entire session of the legislature.
Fast forward four months and Virginia is slowly — some may say rapidly — regaining its reputation as an ultraconservative state because of the debate about the transvaginal ultrasound. Requiring either type of ultrasound for an abortion is a move aimed to satisfy social conservative voters and legislators at the expense of women seeking a legal medical procedure.
There is a bit of irony that this is occurring right as these same conservatives are revolting in regard to the mandates of the federal health care legislation.
This is not an attempt to denigrate the pro-life movement. There is a real and genuine disagreement in our society about when life truly begins and the morality and necessity of abortion. Both sides believe they’re on the right side of history, but the truth of the matter is we as a society haven’t made up our minds.
And the recent vote in the General Assembly will certainly propel the issue back into the spotlight. Perhaps that’s a good thing. If the government has the intention of making these decisions for women — and frankly for all the voters — then it needs to be much more a part of the national and local debate.
With the upcoming presidential and Senate campaigns just about to kick off, be careful what you wish for.