chuckhoffmann Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> The biggest problem I can see with this program is
> that it looks like it's more of a revenue
> generator than a legitimate law enforcement tool.
>
> Passing a school bus in Virginia is statutorily
> defined as reckless driving by § 46.2-859, which
> is wholly appropriate considering that there's a
> chance that some little kid could wind up as
> roadkill because of some dickhead in a hurry.
>
> Reckless driving in the Commonwealth is a pretty
> serious misdemeanor; you can be fined up to $2500
> and do up to a year in your local ADC.
> Additionally, they slap 6 naughty points on your
> license and in particularly egregious cases the
> judge will straight-up suspend your license.
>
> The enabling legislation that includes the video
> camera monitoring provision (§ 46.2-844) makes
> passing a stopped school a civil offense rather
> than a criminal one and imposes a $250 civil
> penalty. Further, the law specifically states that
> if you're charged under § 46.2-844 you cannot be
> charged under § 46.2-859, so you're subject to a
> much lesser financial hit and no risk of jail
> time.
>
> Adding video cameras to school buses to catch
> people who pass stopped school buses is a fine
> idea, but hiring private companies to do it and
> giving them a chunk of the revenue under a
> neutered version of the law is a shit one.
>
> See
>
http://law.lis.virginia.gov/vacode/title46.2/chapt
> er8/section46.2-844/ and
>
http://law.lis.virginia.gov/vacode/title46.2/chapt
> er8/section46.2-859/
I agree. Im more interested in the crime than the fine in this case. I am opposed to criminal charges brought by camera unless there is pristine chain of evidence protocol, clear driver id (not just the car) and somehow a human witness to face in court. Not likely these can be met.
Passing a school bus with lights on is one of the most serious offenses a driver can commit. It should be prosecuted as a crime not just a fine. Authorities feel that a civil fine is more easily enforceable, which is true if you ignore constitutional protections...