Illegal Immigration is ILLEGAL! Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Illegal immigrants: Where are they now?
>
http://www.insidenova.com/headlines/illegal-immigr
> ants-where-are-they-now/article_341c311a-060f-11e4
> -b933-0019bb2963f4.html
>
> Illegal immigration is once again a hot topic in
> Prince William County.
>
> Board of supervisors Chairman Corey Stewart wants
> to force federal officials to say whether
> they’ve deported – or released -- an estimated
> 7,000 undocumented residents arrested by local
> police since 2008.
>
> Stewart, R-At Large, has asked the board to vote
> this month on sending a Freedom of Information Act
> request to the U.S. Department of Homeland
> Security to determine the whereabouts of people
> who have been arrested in the county and later
> turned over to U.S. Immigration and Customs
> Enforcement officials.
>
> Federal officials have so far refused to share
> that information with the county. But at least
> some of those arrested have returned to the area,
> Stewart said, because about 700 have been
> re-arrested by police for other crimes over the
> years.
>
> Stewart acknowledges that revisiting the
> immigration issue will likely remind residents of
> the county’s past controversial efforts to crack
> down on undocumented residents – some of which
> made national headlines. But he says the measure
> has nothing to do with racial profiling or any
> attempt to actively seek out recent immigrants.
>
> Instead, Stewart says, the county simply wants to
> follow up on the whereabouts of arrestees
> suspected of being in the country illegally.
>
> “I certainly don’t want to refight those
> battles, but this is a public safety concern first
> and foremost,” Stewart said. “What we’re
> trying to do is find out what the government did
> with these illegal alien criminals, some of whom
> are fairly dangerous.”
>
> According to the 2013 Prince William County crime
> report, 496 people who lacked sufficient documents
> to live in the U.S. were arrested for crimes last
> year. That’s about 1 percent of the total number
> of county arrests.
>
> The majority of those arrests – about 85 percent
> – were for traffic and misdemeanor charges while
> about 15 percent were for felonies, according to
> the report.
>
> Some of Stewart’s fellow supervisors said they
> are surprised Stewart is raising the issue now and
> wondered aloud if the effort might be rooted in
> politics -- now that illegal immigration is once
> again making national headlines.
>
> Supervisor Maureen Caddigan, R-Potomac, said
> Stewart’s proposal seemed a bit “out of the
> blue.” She also wonders whether it’s worth the
> effort.
>
> “I have some questions about it,” she said.
> “We did this once before it gave us a black eye,
> and I guess my question is, with ICE, what is the
> FOIA going to cost?... Is it going to do any good?
> I guess I was really wondering what the purpose
> is.”
>
> Caddigan called the recent arrival of
> unaccompanied immigrant children, thousands of
> whom are being detained in Arizona and Texas,
> “heartbreaking” and said more needs to be done
> to secure the nation’s borders. But she said
> immigration is a federal issue and not something
> the county has power to do anything about.
>
> “We have people who are elected to work on those
> types of things,” she said. “I just don’t
> know why it’s on our level.”
>
> Supervisor John Jenkins, D-Neabsco, said he
> hasn’t decided how he will vote and said he
> needs more information.
>
> “I’m trying to figure out what damage is being
> done by status quo, I guess,” Jenkins said. “I
> don’t have enough information to say right now,
> but I think we should get more support from the
> federal government on identifying and treating the
> problem.”
>
> Supervisor Pete Candland, R-Gainesville, said
> he’ll likely support the proposal simply because
> he’s always in favor of gathering more
> information.
>
> But Candland also said he hopes to hear from
> law-enforcement officials about the need for the
> measure and whether there’s been a recent uptick
> in crime committed by undocumented residents.
>
> “I hope [the measure] is rooted in some sort of
> facts, that there’s some sort of indication this
> will have a practical effect,” Candland said.
> “And I guess the FOIA will let us know.”
>
> If the board approves the measure, it will mark
> the third time the county has attempted to obtain
> information on those referred to ICE as part of an
> agreement the county has had with ICE since 2008.
>
> The program enables jail officers to check
> arrestees’ immigration status against an ICE
> database. If they are found to lack proper
> documents, their cases are referred to ICE. It’s
> unclear, however, whether the arrestees are
> physically transferred to ICE custody. Stewart
> said transfers are made to ICE after arrestees’
> cases are adjudicated by local courts.
>
> The county filed its first and second FOIAs with
> DHS in 2010 after Benedictine nun Denise Mosier
> was killed by a vehicle driven by Carlos A.
> Martinelly-Montano, then 24, who was determined to
> have entered the U.S. illegally from Bolivia with
> his family in 1996, when he was about 10 years
> old.
>
> Martinelly-Montano, who was convicted on charges
> related to the fatal crash and is serving a prison
> term, had been convicted on drunk driving charges
> twice before the wreck. After the second
> conviction in 2008, Prince William County
> officials referred his case to ICE officials.
> Martinelly-Montano was a awaiting a deportation
> hearing when the crash occurred.
>
> The county learned the details of
> Martinelly-Montano’s immigration status because
> of a FOIA request issued in 2010 for his “alien
> file,” which detailed how DHS followed up with
> his case following the 2008 arrest.
>
> A second FOIA request was made for the alien files
> of every person detained from Prince William
> County between Jan. 1, 2008 and Nov. 22, 2010, the
> date the FOIA was issued, according to information
> provided by Prince William County Attorney Angela
> Horan’s office.
>
> Federal officials initially refused to share
> Martinelly-Montano’s file, so the county filed a
> lawsuit and won a court order forcing DHS to turn
> over the file.
>
> DHS responded to the second FOIA in February 2011,
> but only after county officials sought assistance
> from members of Congress.
>
> But the information provided, a heavily redacted
> DHS spreadsheet, did not contain the information
> county officials were looking for. So the county
> filed a second lawsuit in U.S. District Court that
> was eventually dismissed when the judge directed
> county attorneys to exhaust “all administrative
> remedies” with DHS first, Horan wrote.
>
> Stewart says he suspects the new effort will also
> eventually end up in court. According to Horan,
> the previous legal effort cost about $1,500 in
> county attorneys’ time, and the new effort would
> likely be similar.
>
> “This effort would likely be in that
> ballpark,” Horan wrote. “However, costs could
> be higher, depending on the amount of staff
> resources ultimately required.”
Melvin Noe Sanchez-Izaguirre, a citizen of El Salvador and Honduras, was arrested last year in Manassas on an attempted murder charge after he had already been removed once from the U.S. He has since been deported again. Photo credit: Immigration and Customs Enforcement
Attachments: