HomeFairfax General ForumArrest/Ticket SearchWiki newPictures/VideosChatArticlesLinksAbout
Fairfax County General :  Fairfax Underground fairfax underground logo
Welcome to Fairfax Underground, a project site designed to improve communication among residents of Fairfax County, VA. Feel free to post anything Northern Virginia residents would find interesting.
Supreme Court declines to take up Episcopal Church dispute
Posted by: NOVA Politics ()
Date: March 11, 2014 06:43AM

Court declines to take up Episcopal Church dispute
Supreme Court won't hear dispute over Episcopal Church property in northern Va.
http://www.wtop.com/149/3578301/Court-declines-to-take-up-Episcopal-Church-dispute

WASHINGTON (AP) -- The Supreme Court has declined to wade into a dispute between the Episcopal Church and a conservative congregation that left the denomination in a rift over homosexuality and other issues.

The justices on Monday rejected an appeal from The Falls Church, one of seven Virginia congregations that broke away from the Episcopal Church in 2006 and aligned itself with the more conservative Anglican Church of North America.

The breakaway congregation in suburban Washington, D.C., claimed a right to keep the church building and surrounding property. But the Virginia Supreme Court ruled the Episcopal Church retained ownership of the historic church.

The Falls Church was one of seven Virginia congregations that left the Episcopal Church because of theological differences, including the 2003 consecration of an openly gay bishop in New Hampshire.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: Supreme Court declines to take up Episcopal Church dispute
Posted by: more info ()
Date: March 11, 2014 07:55AM

Episcopal Church owns Falls Church property; Supreme Court lets Virginia court ruling stand
http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/episcopal-church-owns-falls-church-property-supreme-court-lets-virginia-court-ruling-stand/2014/03/10/26a17c72-9d5d-11e3-b8d8-94577ff66b28_story.html

Katherine Frey/The Washington Post - The United States Supreme Court affirmed the Virginia Supreme Court ruling awarding the building for the Episcopal Church of Falls Church to The Episcopal Diocese of Virginia. The justices gave no reason for declining to review the decision of the Virginia Supreme Court that the 3,000-member congregation, which voted in 2006 to leave the Episcopal Church, did not have the right to keep the sprawling
Attachments:
fallschurch041394478313.jpg

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: Supreme Court declines to take up Episcopal Church dispute
Posted by: xN3Ep ()
Date: March 11, 2014 11:27AM

The United States Supreme Court affirmed the Virginia Supreme Court ruling awarding the building for the Episcopal Church of Falls Church to The Episcopal Diocese of Virginia

That means they affirmed the owner is the Episcopal church

that people from dc cannot just walk in, call it theirs, and a year later sell it for profit

HAPPENS ALL THE TIME. this isn't a new suit it's a tired suit.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: Supreme Court declines to take up Episcopal Church dispute
Posted by: XcjxG ()
Date: March 11, 2014 11:33AM

that building is a BEAUTY of architecure worthy of praise

i'd elect it for a Historic site if i didn't know the damn facists would rape the place hiring girlfriend and family to spend shitloads of park money - a hell load more than it costs the dead white Episcopalians who built and paid for it

...

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: Supreme Court declines to take up Episcopal Church dispute
Posted by: dKjjd ()
Date: March 11, 2014 11:34AM

hey this is some building no one is using. some dead white american trash left it behind.

let's keep everyone out then sell it

it's not like they want it back

Options: ReplyQuote
After 7 Years, U.S. Supreme Court Issues Final Word: The F.C. Belongs to Diocese
Posted by: Outcome ()
Date: March 13, 2014 07:05AM

After 7 Years, U.S. Supreme Court Issues Final Word: The F.C. Belongs to Diocese
http://fcnp.com/2014/03/12/after-7-years-u-s-supreme-court-issues-final-word-the-f-c-belongs-to-diocese/

The U.S. Supreme Court announced this Monday its denial of an appeal from the congregants who defected from the Falls Church Episcopal Church in 2006, letting stand Fairfax Circuit Court’s ruling that the property of the historic church remains in the possession of the Episcopal Diocese of Virginia.

Monday’s announcement finally exhausts the legal appeals of the ruling available to the defectors, ending eight years of contention which began with the defectors’ vote to leave the Episcopal Church in December 2006, to align with an Anglican bishop from Nigeria and to subsequently occupy the church property for over six years before before being mandated by the Fairfax court to vacate the site in 2012.

Central to the rift that led to the defection was the issue of homosexuality, specifically that the conservative rector at the church, Rev. John Yates, led the defection and subsequent occupation of the property that was ruled illegal, because of his opposition to the national Episcopal Church denomination’s election of an openly gay priest, the Rev. Gene Robinson, to standing as a bishop in 2003.

Yates and the other defectors, including a majority among 11 Virginian Episcopal churches at one point, upon leaving the Episcopal Church, aligned with the Nigerian Anglican Archbishop Peter Akinola to form something called the Congregation of Anglicans in North America (CANA). That was due in part to the bishop’s strident opposition to homosexuality that recently contributed to laws in Nigeria making homosexuality punishable by severe imprisonment.

A congregation of “continuing Episcopalians” composed of Falls Church congregants who voted against the defection, has occupied the history property since May 2012 after a Virginia Circuit Court ruling went in favor of the Episcopal Church.

Now under the leadership of the Rev. John Ohmer (the Episcopalians having defrocked Yates in 2007), the “continuing Episcopalians” have restored two weekly services at the historic Falls Church property, and will host representatives of seven other Episcopal churches in the region for a Great Vigil of Easter service on Saturday April 12. That evening will also mark joining the church by new members. Growth in the size of the congregation has begun to mushroom, Rev. Ohmer told the News-Press.

The Virginia Diocese’s Rt. Rev. Susan Goff, the Bishop Suffragen of the diocese, will be present for that event.

Meanwhile, the defector congregants have continued to worship at alternative sites in the region since being expelled from the Falls Church property in May 2012, and may be moving soon to purchase property for a new church structure.

Court documents coming to light now include a letter from an attorney for the defectors, Steffen N. Johnson, in January 2007, just a month after the vote to defect, explicitly threatening the Diocese and any “continuing Episcopalian” officials from stepping onto the Falls Church property, and also that of the Truro Church in the City of Fairfax, as well, that the defectors had claimed for themselves. The letter stated:

“Given the Congregations’ (defectors—ed.) ownership, possession, and past and ongoing use of their properties, we expect that that neither the Diocese nor TEC (national Episcopal church—ed.) would want to expose itself to the substantial legal risk – including liability for trespass, unlawful entry, breach of the peace, and any other remedies allowed by law – that would be entailed in any attempt to engage in ‘self help’ by attempting to take possession of either congregation’s property or to place another priest in charge of the church premises…By receipt of this letter, you are on notice that no TEC of Diocesan official, employee, or any agent may set foot on either congregation’s property without the express permission from that congregation’s vestry.”

Both sides in the legal dispute issued public statements after Monday’s U.S. Supreme Court was announced.

Diocese of Virginia Statement

The following is a letter issued by the Rt. Rev. Shannon S. Johnston, Episcopalian Bishop of Virginia:

“Today is an important day for our Diocese. We finally can say, with great thankfulness, that the Diocese of Virginia no longer is involved in property litigation. The U.S. Supreme Court has denied the Falls Church CANA’s petition. That means The Falls Church Episcopal is free to continue to worship and grow in its home church buildings.

“Although today marks an official and much anticipated end to the litigation, it also marks a beginning. We will now be able to focus fully our attentions on the many truly exciting ministries all over our Diocese. I pray that those in the CANA congregations will join us in turning this fresh page.

“It is most appropriate that this decision comes at this time, following January’s Annual Council, where we gathered under the theme, “Awake, My Soul, Stretch Every Nerve.” In the spirit of renewal I have felt all over the Diocese, I invite you to join me and your brothers and sisters in 182 congregations as we explore new ways to awake our collective souls; as we take a fresh look at our shared ministries; as we stretch every nerve, beyond our comfort zones; and as we breathe new life into the mission we do together in the name of Jesus Christ.

“Our Dayspring team already has been making great headway in identifying sources of renewed energy and vision involving those properties that have been returned to us as a result of the litigation. I have no doubt that this spirit of renewal will be enhanced by today’s decision. Please join us on this missional journey that will stretch and inspire us as we find new ways to connect our faith community to the needs of the world.

“On this special day, I would like to recognize the clergy and lay leaders of The Falls Church Episcopal, a congregation that has continued to grow in love throughout this prolonged legal process. As always, our prayers remain with all of those affected by the litigation – brothers and sisters who now have the precious opportunity for a new beginning.

“Faithfully, The Rt. Rev. Shannon S. Johnston, Bishop of Virginia.”

Falls Church Anglican Statement

In an e-letter, the Falls Church Anglicans Rector John Yates and two vestrymen of that body issued the following statement on the Supreme Court ruling:

“We received word today that the United States Supreme Court has denied our church’s petition for certiorari and declined to hear our case. This means that the long legal process in which our church has been involved since we were sued by The Episcopal Church and the Episcopal Diocese of Virginia in 2007 has come to its end.

“We have pursued this legal process out of the conviction that it is one of the ministries that God has entrusted to our church and out of our desire to be faithful to God’s calling to see it through to the end. We are grateful that our nation’s civil justice system allows us this recourse and we thank the Supreme Court for its consideration of our petition.

“We will keep praying for the many churches and dioceses that remain embroiled in lawsuits over their property with The Episcopal Church or other denominations. We will continue to pray for clarification of this area of law, which has become increasing convoluted and confusing for the lower courts since the Supreme Court last addressed it in 1979.

“Although we hoped and prayed for a different outcome, we know that God is good, loving, and faithful. We have seen this on vibrant display in so many ways in our life together during these years, and we will continue to trust that He has even better things for us. The legal process may be finished, but in the end only God’s judgment is final and only God’s judgment matters. Our prayer has always been that God would be pleased with us for fighting the good fight, finishing the race, and keeping the faith. (2 Tim. 4:7)

“We move forward into this next season in our life together with great excitement and anticipation-and without regret. By God’s grace and fully relying on His good providence, we’ll energetically pursue all of the other ministries that God has entrusted to our church:

“We will continue to faithfully preach the Gospel of Jesus Christ, crucified and risen again, “the power of God and the wisdom of God.” (1 Cor. 1:23-25) We will continue to share God’s love with our community and with the world. We will continue to plant daughter churches in our communities and beyond. We will continue with our ministries of worship, outreach, discipleship, youth ministry, healing prayer, and so many others. We will re-double our efforts to pray and pursue a new church home, trusting that God’s good plans for us are exceeding abundantly above all that we ask or think.

“May God be glorified in all these efforts. In the family, John Yates, Rector Whit Jordan, Senior Warden, Kristen Short, Junior Warden”

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: Supreme Court declines to take up Episcopal Church dispute
Posted by: deep end ()
Date: March 13, 2014 10:51AM

The Episcopal Church has gone so far off the theologically liberal deep end that I imagine in a few years there will be plenty of empty Episcopal buildings ready to be scooped up by other churches. They won this battle, but long-term trends don't seem to be in their favor.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: Supreme Court declines to take up Episcopal Church dispute
Posted by: Bill.N. ()
Date: March 13, 2014 11:46AM

The problems with the Episcopal church and other mainline protestant denominations have little to do with them skewing left. More likely these churches are skewing left (or right) because of the problems they are having. When you are a "big tent" operation and the middle deserts you, it leaves those at the extremes with more power.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: Supreme Court declines to take up Episcopal Church dispute
Posted by: True The Vote ! ()
Date: March 13, 2014 12:51PM

This story is like the Republicans and devout conservatives.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: Supreme Court declines to take up Episcopal Church dispute
Posted by: y9Ete ()
Date: March 13, 2014 02:38PM

i can't blame the USSC for declining the case because infact there are many same cases in 2,000 per state in 53 states every year (thousands)

-----------------------------------
however i can say they took JANET JACKSON'S BOOBS case and let her off the hook

instead of doing real work

today the FCC is allowing not only porn talk and in some cases porn on tv

they are allowing "carnal knowlege" tv and murder tv (ie, death and guts game shows where getting heads blown off wins a prize, and other shows with similar really killer inuendo: which is more illegal than sexual inuendo)

------------------------------------
USSC has left the bank doors open to gov and insiders.

USSC has rejected any sense of public responsibility owed

USSC has enabled county level facists to borrow and spend and falsely prosecute, to use cops as militia against the poor (to cull political competition and legal complains) freely. without repercussion, silently

USSC is responsible for the court system, the DOJ/AO is by Constitution an agency USSC runs, and USSC simply is NOT managing a thing.

DOJ even threatens judges by mail to give no justice quickly, never award the poor, or they are fire and loose their $150,000 / yr pay. and to use microsoft products to delay court at least a month in all cases: which previously had been illegal. time is legal injury.

I SAW SUCH MEMOS

I CHALLENGE THE DOJ

SHAME ON THE USSC FOR NOT MANAGING THE COURT SYSTEM BETTER

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: Supreme Court declines to take up Episcopal Church dispute
Posted by: deep end ()
Date: March 14, 2014 02:08AM

Bill.N. Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> The problems with the Episcopal church and other
> mainline protestant denominations have little to
> do with them skewing left. More likely these
> churches are skewing left (or right) because of
> the problems they are having. When you are a "big
> tent" operation and the middle deserts you, it
> leaves those at the extremes with more power.


I specifically used the term "theologically liberal" to distinguish it from just "liberal," which, with no preceding adjective, is usually taken to mean the political sense. Although there is some affinity, the distinction is important as it is the former sense that has been causing the problem here, and will do so into the future.

In fact, this has been a historical trend since the rise of Higher Criticism in the early 1800's and is responsible for many of the different church factions we see today. The problem / divide has become more prominent in the past 50 years, and the whole Episcopal / Anglican split is just one more example.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: Supreme Court declines to take up Episcopal Church dispute
Posted by: 43bnu ()
Date: March 14, 2014 07:36AM

deep end Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> The Episcopal Church has gone so far off the
> theologically liberal deep end that I imagine in a
> few years there will be plenty of empty Episcopal
> buildings ready to be scooped up by other
> churches. They won this battle, but long-term
> trends don't seem to be in their favor.

Agreed.

Options: ReplyQuote


Your Name: 
Your Email (Optional): 
Subject: 
Attach a file
  • No file can be larger than 75 MB
  • All files together cannot be larger than 300 MB
  • 30 more file(s) can be attached to this message
Spam prevention:
Please, enter the code that you see below in the input field. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
 ********  ********  **     **  **          ******   
    **     **        **     **  **    **   **    **  
    **     **        **     **  **    **   **        
    **     ******    **     **  **    **   **   **** 
    **     **         **   **   *********  **    **  
    **     **          ** **          **   **    **  
    **     ********     ***           **    ******   
This forum powered by Phorum.